Journal Press India^®

Author Details ( * ) denotes Corresponding author

The new challenges of globalisation have made it essential to achieve and sustain a high level of efficiency in the provision of healthcare. Even though the Government of Maharashtra clearly views assuring efficiency and providing public health services to the people as an important policy objective, data reveals that the amount of resources spent on public healthcare especially public hospitals is very meagre as compared to the needs of the population. This study attempts to understand the shift from public to the private health sector by the users of health services in the city of Mumbai. This changing trend towards increasing use of private hospitals for healthcare services was analysed to understand the specific reasons behind the privatisation of health services in this metropolitan city. Using primary survey, the analysis revealed that majority of the users preferred private hospital services due to various reasons like cleanliness, better infrastructure, efficient and competent doctors and other staff. The results also indicated significant inefficiencies in the functioning of the public hospitals as noted from the responses of the users.

Keywords

Healthcare, Private sector, Economic reforms

1. Bal, A. (2003), The Budget has Promoted the Private Healthcare at the Cost of Public Sector, Express Healthcare Management Journal, 16-31 March, 4(5).
2. Census of India Reports (various years), 2001 and 2011, Government of India.
3. Chakravarti, I. (2009), Draft National Health Bill: Health Reforms for Market not for People Liberation.
4. Crisil Research (2009), Independent Equity Research- Apollo Hospital Enterprise Private Limited, (retrieved from www.apollohospitals.com).
5. Duggal, R & Nandraj, S (1991), Regulating the Private Health Sector, Medico Friend Circle, July-August, Bulletin No 173-174: 5-7.
6. Duggal, R (2003), Privatization of Healthcare in India, Novib Newsletter, The Hague, March, Pgs.2.
7. Duggal, R (2004), Tracing Privatization of Health Care in India, Express Health Care Management, April 1-15.
8. Farrell, M (1957): The Measurement of Productive Efficiency, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 120 (3), pp 253-290.
9. Gangolli, V & Duggal, R (2005), Review of Health Care in India, January, CEHAT Publications, Mumbai.
10. George, A & Nandraj, S (1993), State of Health Care in Maharashtra, Economic and Political Weekly, Aug7-14, Vol 28, No 32 and 33.
11. Ghuman, B & Mehta, A (2009), Health Services in India; Problems and Prospects, International Conference on the Asian Social Protection in Comparative Perspective at National University of Singapore, 7-9 January.
12. Government of Maharashtra, Law and Judiciary Department, Bombay Nursing Home Registration Act, 1949.
13. Goel, D (2002), Impact of Infrastructure on Productivity: Case of Indian Registered Manufacturing, Centre for Development Economics, Working Paper No 106, Delhi School of Economics, New Delhi.
14. Health Spending in India (2011), European Union Health Official Development Assistance and Aid Effectiveness, Country Briefing 6, December, German Foundation for World Population, Germany.
15. International Labour Organization, (2009), Indian Health Sector, Industry Report (retrieved from www.indialawoffices.com/industry_reports.php).
16. Jilani, A., Azhar, G., Jilani, N. & Siddiqui, A. (2009), Private providers of Healthcare in India: A Policy Analysis, The Internet Journal of Third World Medicine, 8(1).
17. Karne, M. (2004), Decentralization of Infrastructural Services, unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Economics, University of Mumbai.
18. Nadkarni, S. (2010), Health Care System is an Industry, Management of the Sick Healthcare System, Vora Medical Publications, 1st Edition.
19. Nandraj, S. Khot, A Menon, S. & Brugha, R. (2001), A Stake Holder Approach towards Hospital Accreditation in India, Health Policy and Planning, A Journal on Health in Development, December, 16 (2): 70-79.
20. Pinto & Udwadia (2010), Private Patient Perceptions about a Public programme; What do Private Indian Tuberculosis Patients really feel about directly observed treatment?, BMC Public Health, Vol 10.
21. World Bank (1993), Investing in Health, World Development Report, Oxford University Press, New York.
22. World Health Report (2000), Health Systems-Improving Performance, World Health Organization, Geneva.
23. World Health Organization (1992), Basic Document, 39^th Edition , Geneva.